noelleon69
Super Freak
Story goes like this, ROTK was just screen on TV where i'm from and some guy from another forum that i visit was asking: "there is a part where they showed Arwen alone after King Aragon has died and Arwen will live forever and ever in loneliness. Is that really what happened in the end?"
So i replied with my best knowledge: "aragorn is only mortal so yes he will one day die first. arwen also dies later because her loved one has passed and found loneliness too hard to bear. she does not live forever because when she married aragorn she is no longer immortal."
Am i correct? And then another guy challenges me by saying: "Then why does Elrond initially objected Arwen from seeing Aragon? He didnt want Arwen to live alone when Aragon dies (thru passage of time or by the sword).... That means Arwen will still be immortal even when she marries Aragon..."
So what is the best way to reply regarding why elrond does not prefer arwen to marry aragorn and also about arwen's mortality etc...
So i replied with my best knowledge: "aragorn is only mortal so yes he will one day die first. arwen also dies later because her loved one has passed and found loneliness too hard to bear. she does not live forever because when she married aragorn she is no longer immortal."
Am i correct? And then another guy challenges me by saying: "Then why does Elrond initially objected Arwen from seeing Aragon? He didnt want Arwen to live alone when Aragon dies (thru passage of time or by the sword).... That means Arwen will still be immortal even when she marries Aragon..."
So what is the best way to reply regarding why elrond does not prefer arwen to marry aragorn and also about arwen's mortality etc...