Rank the LOTR/Hobbit films

[Khev]

We can do this again when the Hobbit trilogy is finished but for now what order do you rank the four Peter Jackson Middle-Earth films? You can rank either by preference or quality, your call.

 

[The Josh]

We need a poll with this too Khev. Come on Now!

FOTR EE
ROTK EE
TTT EE
The Hobbit: AUJ

 

[NAZGUL-KING]

fotr

ttt

rotk

auj

 

[cokebabies]

TTT
ROTK
FOTR
Hobbit

 

[Jen]

FOTR
TTT
ROTK
Hobbit - AUJ

Interesting that I rank them in the order they were all made...

 

[carbo-fation]

LOTR
Hobbit:AUJ

 

[EVILFACE]

FotR

TTT



RotK


























The 80's cartoon versions.



























The Hobbit

 

[RIDDICK]

EVILFACE has spoken, close da thread

 

[DinoDB1975]

As you said Khev, too early...

but

FOTR
ROTK
AUJ
TTT

 

[SnakeDoctor]

(1) Last 2/3 of Fellowship of the Ring.



Haven't seen the rest.

From the look of these lists ... its downhill from there.

SnakeDoc

 

[The Josh]

(1) Last 2/3 of Fellowship of the Ring.



Haven't seen the rest.

From the look of these lists ... its downhill from there.

SnakeDoc

Not even close.

 

[pixletwin]

FotR
ROtK
AUJ
TTT

 

[rushmore223]

Fellowship

Return of the King

Two Towers

Unexpected Journey

I bet many filmmakers wish they had 4 films of this quality to put on their resume

 

[uscmhicks]

Fellowship
Two Towers
Return of the King

Still not seen the Hobbit....

 

[SnakeDoctor]

Not even close.

Close enough. So far, every list but one has Fellowship first.

SnakeDoc

 

[Adolfo]

Hobbit, FOTR,ROTK, TTT

 

[The Josh]

Close enough. So far, every list but one has Fellowship first.

SnakeDoc

That doesn't mean each movie afterwards is actually worse. All four movies IMO are very good.

 

[Adolfo]

That doesn't mean each movie afterwards is actually worse. All four movies IMO are very good.

yup

 

[RIDDICK]

Actually yes, FotR is superior.

 

[scarecrow jim]

ROTK
FOTR
TT
Hobbit