Well I do believe both trilogies have different feels to them, OT being more concentrated on the characters and the PT having a bit broader scope and landscape, but I like them both. The only things that always bother me with the PT are Anakin's perky attitude on Tattooine, he just seemed to chipper for basically being Watto's _____, and the pickup shoot wig effects with Obi-Wan in Episode 1 and 2, it's so blatant and horrible when he's wearing the wigs and fake beard, I shudder looking at them, it was the greatest joy when ROTS was in production and they announced Ewan would be maintaining his natural hair and beard for the pickups. I'm also not a fan of killing off Maul,
but that's personal taste vs. movie quality