Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier (SPOILERS)

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

I'll tell you, but, since there are two after-credits scenes, first things first:

1.)Do you know who the Winter Soldier is?

2.) Do you care if I tell you who he is?
I'm well awake of who he is, read the comics. I was actually rather surprised that his identity was a secret/spoiler to begin with. Thought it was obvious from the trailer alone and the cast listing for the movie reveals it.
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

Well, then, here we go:

Spoiler Spoiler:
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

Couldn't agree more Batfan. The action is fast and packed in, but its the great performances put in that really made this movie. Redford...no surprise there, but Mackie was an unkown to me and he really impressed me. It didn't feel like Captain America... and some dudes that follow him around, it really had a feel of comrades in arms. And it was realy gut wrenching...


Spoiler Spoiler:
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

Well, then, here we go:

Spoiler Spoiler:
Both sound great. I'm happy that the first one

Spoiler Spoiler:
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

The first big fight between Cap and WS was mind blowing with how the sound effects and music were presented.

Battle looked great even when Cap was in street clothes.

This movie rocks.
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

The first big fight between Cap and WS was mind blowing with how the sound effects and music were presented.

Battle looked great even when Cap was in street clothes.

This movie rocks.

Everyone in my theater went crazy during that scene
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

Well, then, here we go:

Spoiler Spoiler:

I missed the last Smithsonian scene--gotta watch this movie again!
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

Ahh. Didn't catch that. Thanks!:hi5:

You're welcome my friend. It actually is a very meaningful reference when you think about what went on with both Cap and Fury during the film.
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

Great review batfan! :clap Now you need to change your username to "capfan"

Honestly, this is perhaps one of the strongest Marvel studios movies to date. It was intense, interesting and in my opinion, did a good job of interweaving some characterization in-between the action sequences. Perhaps one of the strongest points of the film was the DIALOGUE. Previous reviews have pointed it out and for a comic book movie, it's sharp and well-done with excellent moments of humor and wit. While I love "The Avengers", some of the dialogue was corny and too forced "comic-booky" ("I have red in my ledger"...), none of that here, "The Winter Soldier" grounds it with a hint of realism and strong performances by the entire cast.

batfan pretty much nailed it with his character descriptions, but I wanted to touch on one thing. This is a Ed Brubaker/Steve Epting CAPTAIN AMERICA comic come to life. You can see their work has strongly influenced this movie (with nothing stronger than "The Winter Soldier" character himself, who was "created" by those two) and if you've been a fan of their work on previous "Captain America" comics, you'll love this movie.

Another thing is that Marvel has slowly groomed the audience to become more comfortable with their futuristic "pseudo-technological advance" modern society. Any fan of Marvel will know that objects like Helicarriers, Holographic communications/disguises, Hovering Quinjets, cyborg arms, etc. etc. are a "normal" thing in the everyday Marvel Universe. In movies however, to just throw them in there would be a shock to the audience in my opinion. However, over the course of the movies they have slowly introduced that the Marvel Cinematic Universe is a highly technical world which is still grounded with some reality. The excess of helicarriers and quinjets here did not strike me as strange at all and neither did the large presence of SHIELD in the world thanks to Marvel's nurturing hand of this technology and organizations over the course of several movies. This goes back to comments I've seen before that part of Marvel studios own movie success is they have fully "embraced" the comic book roots and try not to stray far too much into the dimension of realism (like "The Dark Knight" trilogy).

Spoiler Spoiler:
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

Couldn't agree more Batfan. The action is fast and packed in, but its the great performances put in that really made this movie. Redford...no surprise there, but Mackie was an unkown to me and he really impressed me. It didn't feel like Captain America... and some dudes that follow him around, it really had a feel of comrades in arms. And it was realy gut wrenching...


Spoiler Spoiler:

This film is loaded with performances that are pitch perfect and pack emotional resonance that just wallop you while you sit there watching. And still I come back to two that just hit me hard and brought tears...
Spoiler Spoiler:


I don't know how Whedon tops this next summer. He's gotta bring what he did with those very best episodes of Buffy and Firefly, the ones that stay with you forever, to make Age of Ultron even on the same par as TWS.
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

Maybe Whedon should be kicked to the curb and the Russo bros. should do Avengers 3 :rock
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

Great review batfan! :clap Now you need to change your username to "capfan"

Honestly, this is perhaps one of the strongest Marvel studios movies to date. It was intense, interesting and in my opinion, did a good job of interweaving some characterization in-between the action sequences. Perhaps one of the strongest points of the film was the DIALOGUE. Previous reviews have pointed it out and for a comic book movie, it's sharp and well-done with excellent moments of humor and wit. While I love "The Avengers", some of the dialogue was corny and too forced "comic-booky" ("I have red in my ledger"...), none of that here, "The Winter Soldier" grounds it with a hint of realism and strong performances by the entire cast.

batfan pretty much nailed it with his character descriptions, but I wanted to touch on one thing. This is a Ed Brubaker/Steve Epting CAPTAIN AMERICA comic come to life. You can see their work has strongly influenced this movie (with nothing stronger than "The Winter Soldier" character himself, who was "created" by those two) and if you've been a fan of their work on previous "Captain America" comics, you'll love this movie.

Another thing is that Marvel has slowly groomed the audience to become more comfortable with their futuristic "pseudo-technological advance" modern society. Any fan of Marvel will know that objects like Helicarriers, Holographic communications/disguises, Hovering Quinjets, cyborg arms, etc. etc. are a "normal" thing in the everyday Marvel Universe. In movies however, to just throw them in there would be a shock to the audience in my opinion. However, over the course of the movies they have slowly introduced that the Marvel Cinematic Universe is a highly technical world which is still grounded with some reality. The excess of helicarriers and quinjets here did not strike me as strange at all and neither did the large presence of SHIELD in the world thanks to Marvel's nurturing hand of this technology and organizations over the course of several movies. This goes back to comments I've seen before that part of Marvel studios own movie success is they have fully "embraced" the comic book roots and try not to stray far too much into the dimension of realism (like "The Dark Knight" trilogy).

Spoiler Spoiler:

Absolutely, and I'm glad you touched on Brubaker's run. I've read some of it, but I really just want to sit down and read everything from Issue 1 to the very end, and so, with that in mind, I wasn't going to presume to attest to the legitimacy of it as an adaptation, when I, myself, wasn't familiar enough with it to draw those conclusions.:lol
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

Absolutely, and I'm glad you touched on Brubaker's run. I've read some of it, but I really just want to sit down and read everything from Issue 1 to the very end, and so, with that in mind, I wasn't going to presume to attest to the legitimacy of it as an adaptation, when I, myself, wasn't familiar enough with it to draw those conclusions.:lol

You've got to batfan. Bru's run is genius. And thank you for that fantastic review.
 
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

From what I read, I really want to, but I was borrowing the omnibuses from a buddy of mine, and, unfortunately, he gave me "The Death of Captain America" Omni first; my brain kind of shut down and refused to read it because I wanted to start at issue 1.:lol
 
Last edited:
Re: Captain America 2: The Winter Soldier

Maybe Whedon should be kicked to the curb and the Russo bros. should do Avengers 3 :rock

58DA1AB3-740A-4549-84F2-87E92A0D0267.jpg
 
Back
Top