Re: The First Avenger: Captain America Discussion Thread
Regarding Downey, Jr., even if he did audition, he didn't have to diverge from what he previously did as Iron Man, so in that instance, I would agree with you. But Evans can't act like Johnny Storm or frat-guy, or the guy from Sunshine and hope to pull off Captain America.
I agree with theMike. I don't think Evans has played a character even remotely similar to Rogers/Cap. You can't gauge the ability of someone to play a specific part without seeing how they handle something close to what the character will be. You might have an idea that they have range and know that they can portray some characteristics of a character effectively, but that's about it.Most actors that have a few films under their belt don't have to audition. If you can't tell he can do the job from 3 or 4 previous films, then he's probably not right for it.
Regarding Downey, Jr., even if he did audition, he didn't have to diverge from what he previously did as Iron Man, so in that instance, I would agree with you. But Evans can't act like Johnny Storm or frat-guy, or the guy from Sunshine and hope to pull off Captain America.