The Official "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" movie thread *SPOILERS*

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

Or they could just put his head on another actor's body.....but that's just too...tooo..Lucasish....
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

Thanks for the link Redman.

No worries FOAT.;)


I'm not to concerned at this stage as i'm sure PJ & GDT will find a way to work it out.Like most i'm not too keen on him voicing Smaug but JRD voicing Treebeard didn't worry me at all and i still don't think of Gimli when i hear him say"Now don't be hasty".:D
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

No worries FOAT.;)


I'm not to concerned at this stage as i'm sure PJ & GDT will find a way to work it out.Like most i'm not too keen on him voicing Smaug but JRD voicing Treebeard didn't worry me at all and i still don't think of Gimli when i hear him say"Now don't be hasty".:D


Cristopher Lee has one of the most unique voices in film, so I don't know if he can make it "non-Lee" for Smaug, or if any of us would want him to.

I don't think of Count Dooku when I hear Saruman, or vice versa. I think "Wow, Cristopher Lee is a phenomenal actor".
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

Guillermo Del Toro Says 'Hobbit' "Cannot Serve a Peter Jackson Film"
Posted on Saturday, August 9, 2008

A show of hands here: Who thought Hellboy II not only deserved to make more money but would make more money? With Guillermo Del Toro's blossoming reputation, his selection as the director of The Hobbit, and the groundswell of support for the original Hellboy in the years after its release, the fact that it has, through this weekend, only put about about $75 million is a bit of a surprise.

Of course, it did have The Dark Knight to contend with, but the sequel has been surpassed by Journey to the Center of the Earth and Step Brothers at the U.S. box office, which I certainly didn't see coming.
But Del Toro is ready to move on - sort of - according to a new interview with The Sunday Times. He'll spend much of the next half-decade in New Zealand, working on the prequel to the Lord of the Rings trilogy with producer Peter Jackson, which almost certainly won't have to explain its box office performance to anyone. But the inventive filmmaker admits that, because he covers a lot of the same territory in most of his films, so while he may be working from someone else's material, The Hobbit still attracts him on the same level. The Times says, "All his characters inhabit a universe that is structured but uncaring."
“That’s what I love about fairytales; they tell the truth, not organised politics, religion or economics. Those things destroy the soul," claims Del Toro. "That is the idea from Pan’s Labyrinth and it surfaces in Hellboy and, to some degree, in all my films.”
"I don’t think it’s a conscious decision," the director reasons of his recurring themes, adding, "it’s a proclivity, a compulsion.”
As for The Hobbit, Del Toro says that he can't concern himself with making a carbon copy of the massively popular film series his now-producer Jackson directed:
“I’m trying to be faithful to what I read when I was young. That’s The Hobbit I’m serving. I cannot serve a Peter Jackson film. We also hope to bridge the trilogy. We will create an expansion of what lies in the four books and in a number of appendices. I’m not going to New Zealand for two years to do one movie. I’m going there for four years.”
When asked whether he will find room for the kind of evocative symbolism he's known for in The Hobbit, he replies, “Of course I will...It’s a proclivity, a compulsion.”

The first Hobbit film is currently scheduled for a December 2011 release, with the follow-up arriving a year later.
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

It will truly be disapointing if Lee is not Saruman. I am pretty damn sure nobody else can pull it off as well as he did.

True no one else will pull it off like Christopher
But lets be reasonable he is 86 years old, does not want to travel to NZ and live here for 4 years and there was a hint of doubt in his voice (in the interview regarding The Hobbit) that he will still be alive when the films are released. I think the fans should not be disappointed if he chooses not to partake in The Hobbit and its Sequel
That being said he should have a body double take his place in the film and then have his voice recorded in an English Studio and have his voice put into the film and have the digital effects people make the body double look like Chris in every single way
I think that would work and please his fans at the same time
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

True no one else will pull it off like Christopher
But lets be reasonable he is 86 years old, does not want to travel to NZ and live here for 4 years and there was a hint of doubt in his voice (in the interview regarding The Hobbit) that he will still be alive when the films are released. I think the fans should not be disappointed if he chooses not to partake in The Hobbit and its Sequel
That being said he should have a body double take his place in the film and then have his voice recorded in an English Studio and have his voice put into the film and have the digital effects people make the body double look like Chris in every single way
I think that would work and please his fans at the same time

That's true. I think Christopher's magic lies in particular in his voice. :saruman :orthanc
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

That's true. I think Christopher's magic lies in particular in his voice. :saruman :orthanc

Very True also the power of Saruman is in his voice
".....There is a fell voice in the Air"
"IT'S SARUMANNNNN!!!!"
:D
 
Last edited:
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

I'm glad to see Viggo back I was worried that he wouldn't be involved at all with anything. Hearing that Serkis is going to be back as well is gladly received news.

Being a big Viggo fan, I read alot about him. When he first heard about The Hobbit, he was in. He said he didn't want anyone else playing Aragorn. I'm so glad of that.

This movie is something to look forward too. Star Trek next May and then this possibly the next year!
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

Nice. I am in the midst of reading The History of the Hobbit and it's a great way to get my ready for the movie.:D

Would this be better to read BEFORE reading The Hobbit? I haven't read The Hobbit since I was very young and I want to read it again.
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

Would this be better to read BEFORE reading The Hobbit? I haven't read The Hobbit since I was very young and I want to read it again.

No, I would suggest reading The Hobbit first. The history book is kind of boring and does require you to have read The Hobbit. But if you want to get more info on The Hobbit by simpler means, I would suggest reading the The Annotated Hobbit by Douglas Anderson(https://www.amazon.com/Annotated-Ho...bs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1218406964&sr=8-1). It is a great way to learn more about the book and a lot of the background and historical facts that would otherwise go unnoticed by a casual reader.
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

A bit off topic here: who was supposed to play Aragorn before Viggo was called in? I remember seeing that his casting was pretty much a last minute sort of thing.
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

A bit off topic here: who was supposed to play Aragorn before Viggo was called in? I remember seeing that his casting was pretty much a last minute sort of thing.

Stewart Townsend, and a good choice on the replacement, eh?

:phew smilie
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

And Kevin Conway was the original actor cast as King Theoden. I remember being bummed when he was announced, putting an end to speculation about what bigger names might be chosen. But then it was really good news when Bernard Hill replaced him, as he was more familiar to me after Titanic.
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

And Kevin Conway was the original actor cast as King Theoden. I remember being bummed when he was announced, putting an end to speculation about what bigger names might be chosen. But then it was really good news when Bernard Hill replaced him, as he was more familiar to me after Titanic.

But that's one of the things I loved about LOTR. It wasn't star-studded, it wasn't Hollywood. Orlando Bloom made his name doing LOTR. They chose actors who would fit the character, not the other way around. Otherwise, of course, we would have had Sean Connery as Gandalf :D
 
Re: The Official "The Hobbit" movie thread

Yeah, but recall Connery was approached to do Gandalf first, which he turned down (much to his chagrin). He tried making up for it by doing LXG, but I don't think they could even be put in the same league.
 
Back
Top