Rank the Superhero movies

I say this was starting in the IM3 thread and somebody suggested that I start a thread of it's own so here it is.

Marvel, DC, Image, Dark Horse.....Whatever.. Rank you favorite Superhero films.

I am sure I forgot some (does Kick *** count??) I will put in Red if one is forgotten and put it in it's proper group.

Top Of the Class

1. The Dark Knight
2. The Avengers
3. The Winter Soldier
4. The Incredible Hulk
5. Batman Begins
6. Superman: The Movie
7. Blade
8. Iron Man
9. Spider-Man 2
10. Blade 2
11. X-Men 2
12. The Amazing Spider-Man 2

Teacher's Pet

13. X-Men: Days of Futures Past
14. Superman 2
15. X-Men
17. GotG
17. Spider-Man
18. Thor
19. The Amazing Spider-Man
20. X-Men First Class
21. Captain America
22. Kick ***
23. The Wolverine



Class Clowns

22. The Dark Knight Rises
23. AOU
24. Thor 2
25. Hellboy 2
26. Iron 2
27. Batman
28. Batman Returns
29. X-Men 3
30. Hellboy
31. Fantastic 4: Rise of the Silver Surfer
32. Watchmen



Stay After School

33. MOS
34. Spider-Man 3
35. Wolverine
36. Iron Man 3
37. Batman Forever
38. DareDevil
39. Superman Returns
40. Fantastic Four
41. Ghost Rider


Failing Grade

42. Superman 3
43. Hulk
44. Punisher
45. Ghost Rider 2


Deserve to be held back and killed

46. Blade 3
47. Elektra
48. Superman 4: The Quest for Piece
49. Roger Corman's Fantastic Four
50. Captain America - (80's version)
51. Punisher War Zone
52. Punisher Dulph version

We need a poll with all the comic book movies listed, who's doing it.

jye4ever said:

We need a poll with all the comic book movies listed, who's doing it.

Click to expand...

I would think you could do a poll but it would it would not need all the comic films. I mean who is going to pick Blade 3 or Superman 4?

I would guess you could probably limit down to 10

JAWS said:

I would think you could do a poll but it would it would not need all the comic films. I mean who is going to pick Blade 3 or Superman 4?

I would guess you could probably limit down to 10

Click to expand...

I said comic book films, I really meant Superhero movies.

Now that I got that out of the way, sure, include Blade 3, Elektra, etc.

Lets be thorough.

The Nick Fury film Marvel did in the 90s starring David Hasselhoff needs representation.

jimmie_dimmick said:

The Nick Fury film Marvel did in the 90s starring David Hasselhoff needs representation.

Click to expand...

Well, it needs to have been released in the theaters to be on this poll.

Jaws, you got this.

jimmie_dimmick said:

The Nick Fury film Marvel did in the 90s starring David Hasselhoff needs representation.

Click to expand...

Then make a list and Represent

jye4ever said:

Well, it needs to have been released in the theaters to be on this poll.

Jaws, you got this.
ñ

Click to expand...

yeah. I don't feel Death of the Incredible Hulk needs to be on here.

From favourite to least favourite (of all the ones i've seen)

1. Spider-Man 2
2. X-men 2: X-Men United
3. Superman: The Motion Picture
4. X-Men First Class
5. Watchmen
6. The Incredibles
7. Iron Man
8. Thor
9. Hellboy 2
10. Amazing Spider-Man
11. Batman Begins
12. Captain America: The First Avenger
13. Kickass
14. The Rocketeer
15. X-Men
16. Sin City
17. Blade 2
18. The Dark Knight
19. Spider-Man
20. Hulk
21. Hellboy
22. Batman Returns
23. Blade
24. Superman 3
25. Avengers
26. V for Vendetta
27. 300
28. Batman
29. Superman 2
30. X-Men 3: The Last Stand
31. Daredevil
32. Batman Forever
33. Iron Man 2
34. The Punisher
35. Wolverine: Origins
36. Captain America (90s)
37. Blade Trinity
38. Green Lantern
39. Fantastic Four: Rise of The Silver Surfer
40. The Incredible Hulk
41. Spawn
42. Superman 4: The Quest For Peace
43. Ghost Rider
44. Fantasitc Four
45. Batman & Robin
46. Superman Returns

Iron Man
Batman Begins
Watchmen
The Dark Knight
Men in Black
The Avengers
The Amazing Spiderman
X-Men : First Class
V For Vendetta
Sin City
Hellboy 2
Kick-***
Thor
Iron Man 2
Dredd
X2 : United
The League of Extraordianry Gentlemen
The Incredible Hulk
The Rocketeer
Batman 89
**** Tracy

Uncanny Web-Slinger said:

From favourite to least favourite

1. Spider-Man 2
2. X-men 2: X-Men United
3. Superman
4. X-Men First Class
5. Watchmen
6. Iron Man
7. Thor
8. Hellboy 2
9. Batman Begins
10. Amazing Spider-Man
11. X-Men
12. Captain America: The First Avenger
13. Kick ***
14. Blade 2
15. Hulk
16. The Dark Knight
17. Spider-Man
18. Iron Man 3
19. Hellboy
20. Batman Returns
21. Blade
22. Superman 3
23. Batman 89
24. Avengers
25. Superman 2
26. Daredevil
27. X-Men 3
28. Iron Man 2
29. Captain America (90s)
30. Fantastic Four 2
31. The Incredible Hulk
32. Superman 4
33. Superman Returns

Click to expand...

Save it for the poll.

Polls are easier to remember than personal lists.

It might not represent our personal lists but it would show were these movies fall within the overall fan base.

Then again we could just leave it as our personal lists.

Poll can only have ten, and will be mobbed by Whedonites and Nolanites

This works better as it factors in EVERY superhero / comic book movie. I was surprised at where some of mine placed compared to others.

Still tweaking

Clearly it's:

Iron Man
Iron Man 2
Iron Man 3

Uncanny Web-Slinger said:

Poll can only have ten, and will be mobbed by Whedonite and Nolanites

Click to expand...

Crap, only 10.

Oh well, was worth a thought.

No particular order:

Dredd
IronMan
Watchmen
V
Spiderman 1&2 (Raimi)
X-Men 1,2, FC
Avengers
Hellboy
Nolan Bats
KickAss
Blade

Anything else probably ranks somewhere between pretty good and lol get the **** outta here with that ****.

jye4ever said:

Save it for the poll.

Polls are easier to remember than personal lists.

It might not represent our personal lists but it would show were these movies fall within the overall fan base.

Then again we could just leave it as our personal lists.

Click to expand...

Started Poll. Also add your list to the poll.

https://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/showthread.php?t=127362

JAWS said:

Started Poll. Also add your list to the poll.

https://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/showthread.php?t=127362

Click to expand...

May as well make it TDK Vs Avengers.

Uncanny Web-Slinger said:

Poll can only have ten, and will be mobbed by Whedonites and Nolanites

This works better as it factors in EVERY superhero / comic book movie. I was surprised at where some of mine placed compared to others.

Still tweaking

Click to expand...

Well we will see which thread lives best then go from there

JAWS said:

Started Poll. Also add your list to the poll.

https://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/showthread.php?t=127362

Click to expand...

3 batman movies, vs one of each other character

Deckard said:

May as well make it TDK Vs Avengers.

Click to expand...

I'll just copy my post from the previous thread.

The Avengers
Iron Man
Superman
Thor
Captain America
TDK
89 Batman
Iron Man 2/Iron Man 3
BB
Spider-Man 1