I disagree that the chin looks too chiseled/prominent or that the head is too tall and narrow, but I agree that the nose is too high/small, and I agree that the likeness is not perfect and a bit off. But I'll say it again: it's the best likeness on a statue/figure that there is to date.
Hollywood Collectibles 1/4 Captain Kirk
- Thread starter Jiminydog
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
I disagree that the chin looks too chiseled/prominent or that the head is too tall and narrow, but I agree that the nose is too high/small, and I agree that the likeness is not perfect and a bit off. But I'll say it again: it's the best likeness on a statue/figure that there is to date.
Blackthornone
Super Freak
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2008
- Messages
- 3,682
- Reaction score
- 1
I misspoke. I meant the area under the mouth, above the chin. That recession under the mouth, somewhat like a trapezoid. Now that you posted a bigger picture, I can see that the eyebrows are a bit off as well. They lack the slight curve upwards near the bridge of the nose, and doesn't have enough of an angle downwards towards the outward sides of his eyes. The eyebrows on the statue have too much of a one gentle sweeping curve, while they should have 3 subtle angles to them-up toward the brow, mostly flat in the middle, and downwards at the outside.
Last edited:
Remember, this is a POLYSTONE statue. Show me a better Kirk statue/figure of any material, anywhere. No one has so far, although several have knocked it. I like giving the Devil his due. And this statue is the best I've seen of Kirk (the earlier, 1/6 release from the same company, not withstanding). The other thing to remember is that the prototype as seen in the gallery pics is exactly equal to each production model!
Last edited:
Blackthornone
Super Freak
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2008
- Messages
- 3,682
- Reaction score
- 1
If Hot Toys made a Captain Kirk, I would probably buy. If they made a Mr.Spock, I would definitely buy.
Seems like Bill Shatner's likeness has always been hard to capture in a statue or bust.
I have the Sideshow Kirk and while I like it I have always thought the head was a little too "squashed".
I like this 1/4 Kirk and that's all that matters to me.
I have the Sideshow Kirk and while I like it I have always thought the head was a little too "squashed".
I like this 1/4 Kirk and that's all that matters to me.
Wouldn't that depend what the piece looked like and or on the degree of facial likeness? The Sideshow PF of Kirk that came out a few years ago, for example, was sad as far as I'm concerned.
Ironman1188
SO BE IT
Its better than the Diamond 1/4 scale by far.
Its not so much that he's difficult to capture but that, for some reason, he vetoes decent sculpts and has them redone. I've spoken to a few folks that have sculpted for companies and had that happen.
I guess this isn't so bad for an oversized, static piece. I still think WGP's is good. And....we haven't seen it painted yet. We all know that can make or break a sculpt too.
Its not so much that he's difficult to capture but that, for some reason, he vetoes decent sculpts and has them redone. I've spoken to a few folks that have sculpted for companies and had that happen.
I guess this isn't so bad for an oversized, static piece. I still think WGP's is good. And....we haven't seen it painted yet. We all know that can make or break a sculpt too.
wax murderer
Super Freak
- Joined
- Sep 25, 2005
- Messages
- 1,682
- Reaction score
- 22
Oh, just come out and say it...it doesn't look like Shatner. And he's not unique as far as rejecting likenesses goes.When I was in the model shop we got hit with that all the time(ask me about Elvis some time)...PS
Well, not so fast.... if this piece doesn't look like Shatner, then certainly no other piece does; just come out and say that.
Interesting, I hadn't heard that! But I believe it. The man has an ego bigger than the ship he commanded.
Ironman1188
SO BE IT
Well, not so fast.... if this piece doesn't look like Shatner, then certainly no other piece does; just come out and say that.
Thats rather definitive, I think we need to all admit that its subjective. Some see whats there and others see whats not.
Yes, that's true. But I've also noticed that maybe some folks tend to side with a particular maker that perhaps they favor, almost like rooting for one's team, and tend to dismiss or downgrade another company almost outright. I hope I'm wrong. I like to give the Devil his due and call it as I see it. And I just see this piece as top-notch. In fact, right now HCG offer the best Trek TOS statues (Kirk, Spock and the Gorn commander) in my opinion. I promise, I do not work for nor am I affiliated in any way with HCG.
Last edited:
Yes, that's true. But I've also noticed that maybe some folks tend to side with a particular maker that perhaps they favor, almost like rooting for one's team, and tend to dismiss or downgrade another company almost outright. I hope I'm wrong. I like to give the Devil his due and call it as I see it. And I just see this piece as top-notch. In fact, right now HCG offer the best Trek TOS statues (Kirk, Spock and the Gorn commander) in my opinion. I promise, I do not work for nor am I affiliated in any way with HCG.
very true. but i think many people compare things to their favorite company too. hot toys is now the standard so everyone's always like "if it's not better than hot toys, it's not worth it." truth is hot toys is not gonna produce every single license on earth and we as collectors miss out on some of the more noteworthy products/figures that are released
the hcg statue looks good, but it's still not perfect imho. the sculpt could be improved
Ironman1188
SO BE IT
Even if Hot Toys did TOS now, I really don't see them being better, or even as good as, those that Nanjin already did. To me, thats the bar that was set as far as Trek is concerned. Even Dragon's TNG pale in comparison. And they're a major manufacturer.
Don't know from "Nanjin." Is there a link?
Ironman1188
SO BE IT
He's a member here who undertook getting quality Trek made for us all on his own.
https://sideshowcollectors.com/forums/search.php?searchid=9202504
That link doesn't work for me.
Blackthornone
Super Freak
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2008
- Messages
- 3,682
- Reaction score
- 1
Well, not so fast.... if this piece doesn't look like Shatner, then certainly no other piece does; just come out and say that.
Honestly the Mego 8 inch Captain Kirk was better than the Sideshow PF, and was a decent likeness for a toy.
https://www.megomuseum.com/startrek/captainkirk.html
Last edited:
Similar threads
