I have already cast my vote, Superman's Reeve FTW.
That said, I like MoS and BvS a lot. They're awesome superhero movies. They're just bad Superman movies. Cavill is great and you can see he likes and endorses the character, but what to think of a movie that hates it's source so much?
- Perry White is black. Okay, I can live with it because I love the actor
- They cast Lana Lang in the role of Lois Lane
- Costume looks good, but it's not Superman, unless you're into New 52 which was the worst Superman run ever
- They kill Jimmy Olsen, a CIA agent, WTF? !!!!!!
- They kill Superman AND Clark Kent. Sure, they can bring Supes back, but no way they can realistically bring Clark back
- Tornado
- CK is a reluctant Superman
- Space dildoes
- Superman destroys government property
- Superman kills (okay, I'm fine with that, would have done the same
)
- Jor-El killed by Zod ?
- Mercy killed, for no particular reason, by Lex Luthor
Of course, there's also some good in it (Zod, Faora, great special FX) as there was some bad in Superman (less than awesome plot, ridiculous Luthor, no real motivation for Zod, some stupid powers and stupid ending, though as a kid, it didn't matter) but at least they got the character and the atmosphere right.