Better Trilogy: Raimi's Spider-Man or Nolan's Dark Knight?

[**16k**]

That one's tough!

I enjoyed both trilogies equally, TBH, but I think TDK trilogy is probably more complex, so I'll vote TDK, even though both trilogies have their pros and cons...

 

[JBElliott]

I voted for the Rami/Maguire Spider-Man trilogy. Even with all its problems, it was closer to the comics than the Nolan/Bale Batman movies.

 

[King Darkness]

Spidey only had two good movies, therefore Batman wins by default.

 

[SnakeDoctor]

I voted for the Rami/Maguire Spider-Man trilogy. Even with all its problems, it was closer to the comics than the Nolan/Bale Batman movies.

Is "closer to the comics" necessarily "better"? There are a lot of crap comics out there. I never read any Spider-man comics ... but my understanding is that SM3 pretty well butchered the SM origin story, Harry Osborne, Sandman and Venom.

SnakeDoc

 

[Uncanny Web-Slinger]

Spidey only had two good movies, therefore Batman wins by default.

According to common opinion so did the Nolan trilogy.

 

[jye4ever]

You don't get it because you're mildly (maybe even legally) retarded. You answered your own question, dingus. It's called evolution. Everything from how the characters act on screen to the suit was influenced by Burton beit directly or indirectly through the sequels '89 spawned. Therefore, as I said, without Burton's Batman, there'd be no Nolan Batman.

I think I'm illegally retarded.

 

[thenammagazine]

Is "closer to the comics" necessarily "better"? There are a lot of crap comics out there. I never read any Spider-man comics ... but my understanding is that SM3 pretty well butchered the SM origin story, Harry Osborne, Sandman and Venom.

SnakeDoc

Ignorant bliss?

 

[SnakeDoctor]

I think I'm illegally retarded.

The PC term is "undocumented retarded".

SnakeDoc

 

[Fernandofan08]

20 idjits in the world

 

[Adolfo]

Here's a thought...what if they made a Batman film about one of the Batman Comic book stories...Like Long Halloween just for ex etc...would then Nam and Difabio be happy?

 

[thenammagazine]

Here's a thought...what if they made a Batman film about one of the Batman Comic book stories...Like Long Halloween just for ex etc...would then Nam and Difabio be happy?

Depends. The real TDKR would've been great, but Weller ****ed it up with his inability to act.

 

[Adolfo]

Depends. The real TDKR would've been great, but Weller ****ed it up with his inability to act.

The Frank Miller Dark Knight Returns would be my Live Action Ultimate Batman film if done like in the Comics...even the Toon I gotta admit was very well done

 

[Snadinator]

The Raimy spidey movies habe not held up so well. I recently rewatched them and was reminded just how powerful Nostalgia is.

 

[BladeDJK]

Dark Knight easily. Spider-man 3 really hurt Raimi's trilogy

 

[The Iron Koob]

If you think Nolan would have made it the same or similar youre crazy...Totally different directors...No way Nolan would have been comical like Burton...no freakin way...you dont know what youre talking about

No I don't think Nolan would have made it similar. Nolan wouldn't have touched a batman movie because he would have never been provoked to taking it in a new direction. So obviously Nolan wouldn't have made it comical, that's exactly my point. The first batman movie could have never been Nolan's version because that was evolved. Without burton the films that Nolan would have made would be like Burton's. (but made by someone else because Nolan wouldn't have been provoked to go in his new direction) I hope you get it now. Next time try to read between the lines. Just use ledgers joker as an example. Where do you think Nolan got the idea to make him the way he did? You don't just wake up with that idea, he changed it from the previous versions. Without previous versions...ledger probably never even plays joker.

 

[thenammagazine]

The Frank Miller Dark Knight Returns would be my Live Action Ultimate Batman film if done like in the Comics...even the Toon I gotta admit was very well done

Nah, every time Batman spoke, it took me out of the movie. They made a poor decision going with Weller to play Batman/Bruce. The only reason he worked for RoboCop was because Murphy's an emotionless robot.

 

[CelticPredator]

I love Alien versus Predator: Requiem and don't really like...say, the The Dark Knight.

You can't ****ing talk to me about Transformers ever again. Ever.

 

[Adolfo]

Anyone who votes Nolan over burton is an idiot. They came at two different times and Nolan's movie would be a lot like Burton's if burton hadn't already done it. You think ledgers joker would've been the same if Nicholson hant done it the way he did?

Learn to write better idiot...read between the lines is BS in this statement....Different Directors have different styles...So if Nolan was doing the 89 version it would be like Burtons...no...unless the Studio ordered him its no...why not just say that if the 66 show wasnt around then burtons would not come out like it did....Youve been watching too much of the Sins of the father crap

 

[DiFabio]

Nah, every time Batman spoke, it took me out of the movie.

And Bale's didn't?

 

[PapitoMX]

Voted Nolan. If Rami was allowed to make a better part 3, my vote would have went to his trilogy