The Dark Knight Rises *SPOILERS*
- Thread starter Goonsack Steve
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
- Status
DevilinthePaleMoonlite
Freaked Out
Ok we are getting somewhere, why was Ras wife in the Jail, and did he know she was pregnant? and How did Talia Know to find Ras when she escaped?
Josh-A-Tron
Super Freak
Ras wife was sent to the Pit so he could be free from what? And did he know his wife was pregnant with Talia at the time? Also how did Talia know who her father was when she escaped the PIT? How did she know who to look for?[/QUOTE]
Ras' wife was sent to the Pit because she was promised to another and married Ras in secret. Talia explains that Ras was supposed to also go to the pit but it was decided he would be exiled in the desert instead, unable to help his wife and unborn child.
By the time Talia's mother was killed she looked to be about 6-8 years old, this allows time for the mother to explain exactly who Talia is and who her father is.
The film does not explain how Talia finds Ras, only that she does and bring him back to Release Bane.
- Joined
- May 31, 2011
- Messages
- 16,255
- Reaction score
- 108
"This is Bane's prison now."
Ras was sent free, banished but he didn't have to go into the pit. Talia's mother died the day she escaped the pit, she was a little girl, plenty of time for her mother to tell her about her father.
- Joined
- May 31, 2011
- Messages
- 16,255
- Reaction score
- 108
@ DiFabio's Deleted Post 
The script might have, but Gordon never said who it was in the film...
Who knows, Barb may have been babysitting that night.
In YO Gordon doesn't have a son until the end of the Novel, she's pregnant for 9 months in the book.
The script might have, but Gordon never said who it was in the film...
Who knows, Barb may have been babysitting that night.
In YO Gordon doesn't have a son until the end of the Novel, she's pregnant for 9 months in the book.
DevilinthePaleMoonlite
Freaked Out
Ras' wife was sent to the Pit because she was promised to another and married Ras in secret. Talia explains that Ras was supposed to also go to the pit but it was decided he would be exiled in the desert instead, unable to help his wife and unborn child.
By the time Talia's mother was killed she looked to be about 6-8 years old, this allows time for the mother to explain exactly who Talia is and who her father is.
The film does not explain how Talia finds Ras, only that she does and bring him back to Release Bane.[/QUOTE]
SO ras knew his wife was preggo when she was sent to the pit?
- Joined
- May 31, 2011
- Messages
- 16,255
- Reaction score
- 108
They just said she was with child, not if Ras knew or not.
DevilinthePaleMoonlite
Freaked Out
One more question on this how did Ra's wife die? Did the prisoners just decide one day to kill her?
- Joined
- May 31, 2011
- Messages
- 16,255
- Reaction score
- 108
Presumably she was the only woman in the prison (besides Talia) and the doctor forgot to lock her cell. So the prisoners went mad.
Did you watch the film?
Murderofcrows71
Super Freak
Can anyone tell me why at the end of TDK Bruce Wayne goes into hiding and gives up being Batman (which would never happen), but still finishes the Batcave? Why? If he's done being Batman, why build the Batcave? For those who say it was already built, I say bull. If so he would've been using in TDK it as Wayne Manor was being reconstructed.
DevilinthePaleMoonlite
Freaked Out
Presumably she was the only woman in the prison (besides Talia) and the doctor forgot to lock her cell. So the prisoners went mad.
Did you watch the film?
LOL yes Im tired only seen it once going on true IMAX Friday, Thanks man!
- Joined
- May 31, 2011
- Messages
- 16,255
- Reaction score
- 108
You answered your own question there.
"It will be nice when Wayne Manor is rebuilt"
They were in the process of building it in TDK. He wasn't planning on the Joker attacks happening, Dent turning etc.
Josh-A-Tron
Super Freak
Presumably she was the only woman in the prison (besides Talia) and the doctor forgot to lock her cell. So the prisoners went mad.
Did you watch the film?
I was just going to ask that.
DevilinthePaleMoonlite
Freaked Out
Presumably she was the only woman in the prison (besides Talia) and the doctor forgot to lock her cell. So the prisoners went mad.
Did you watch the film?
Initially why was Bane in the pit was it because his Mercenary work or what? Wasn't that after his escape?
ZsaszSays
Super Freak
The film could scarcely have been more obvious on how Bane escapes. Talia not only tells us explicitly, but Nolan does a flashback to show us.
Then I read some of you confused as to whether Bruce Wayne lives. JFC, do you actually pay attention to the film at all?
DiFabio
Super Freak
- Joined
- Nov 11, 2008
- Messages
- 32,392
- Reaction score
- 2,928
@ DiFabio's Deleted Post
Who knows, Barb may have been babysitting that night.
In YO Gordon doesn't have a son until the end of the Novel, she's pregnant for 9 months in the book.
I didn't delete anything.
The script says it's his son.
145 INT. GORDON’S APARTMENT -- EVENING 145
Gordon’s pregnant wife, BARBARA tries to get their TWO-YEAR
OLD to eat. Gordon picks up the trash.
So it's his son.
In 2004 when Batman Begins was made, they cast a little baby to be Jimmy Gordon. The script called for it, they filmed it. Barbara is feeding him, Gordon is taking out the trash. That's the intent of the scene and the shot.
Just because The Dark Knight was filmed in 2007 and the story takes place between 6 months and a year between Begins and TDK doesn't automatically make that kid a random child. It's an error, plain and simple. My only argument is that visually and story wises, these three films don't connect.
In Begins he's 2. In TDK he's close to 10.
hunnipot85
Super Freak
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2008
- Messages
- 6,399
- Reaction score
- 27
The film could scarcely have been more obvious on how Bane escapes. Talia not only tells us explicitly, but Nolan does a flashback to show us.
Then I read some of you confused as to whether Bruce Wayne lives. JFC, do you actually pay attention to the film at all?
- Joined
- May 31, 2011
- Messages
- 16,255
- Reaction score
- 108
He was presumably born there, like Talia. Which is more likely why he became her protector.
- Status
