I personally think everyone is being too hard on the Supes. I like him. I seen very good pictures of him too. Problem is most haven't. The sculpt on Supes' body is well done. As is his base. Yeah I know most people just don't like his face and wished it more or so had to do with capturing a Reeves, or even the new guy who played him. Or atleast follow the look of a certain artist take on Superman, like your Alex Ross type.
But this Batman also poses certain problems in his sculpt. To me Superman's base is much nicer, and his belt on the Bats just doesn't fit the rest of the costume. Having said that, I still would like to have both pieces in my collection.