1/6 The 5 Black Widow HotToys Compared

Which out of the 5 Black Widow figures do you think is best, and why?

Iron Man 2


The Avengers


The Winter Soldier


Age of Ultron


Civil War

I really liked the winter soldier figure.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Sildedaspo said:

I really liked the winter soldier figure.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Click to expand...

Me as well. I think it's the best one.

I like the hair of the winter soldier, but the best likeness is civil war. I still only have the 1st release.

I did this very rough side by side a while ago.

CW face with WS everything else. Oh, and CW Bucky's assault rifle (it belongs to Natasha anyway).

I like Avengers 1 and Civil War.

I want HT to redo IM 2 BW with a new head sculpt and resize it in scale and I would buy it.

Well to be honest, I think many of the BW figures are essentially the same suit with minor differences, so the biggest thing to me that differentiates them is the quality on the likeness of the sculpt and the hairstyle.

My list on best to worst for me:

1. CW (best sculpt, like the suit)
2. TWS (good sculpt, essentially same suit as CW)
3. A1 (good sculpt, like the CW and TWS suits better)
4. AoU (below average sculpt, decent suit)
5. IM2 (pretty much fails across the board)

That being said, the ones I have are CW, TWS and AoU.

I still prefer the Avengers BW. I feel the recent sculpts aren't pretty enough. They have a good likeness, but somehow aren't as pretty as SJ.

Best likeness is CW hands down, but I like the Avengers suit best because it doesn't limit articulation like the cloth suits do. They should have switched to something like TDKR Catwoman's suit material as it doesn't crease and offers good articulation.

i own all of them except IM2 and id list CW as the best, followed by A1, then TWS and last is AoU.

I'm trying to decide which one I want to add to my collection. I think it comes down to Avengers 1, Winter Soldier, or Civil War lol...

I have two, TWS and AoU. To me the figure just seems better in AoU, although I prefer the look of TWS. Although I've never seen it in hand, the sculpt on the CW figure looks the best in photos..

Now, if this was Thor I can give an in hand opinion on all of them except the sleeveless special edition of TDW.. lol

Had to let go the TWS version. This is the best Bw right now:

I like the A1 best. The material of the suit is tops for me.

CW hair is way too poofy.

HS side-by-side with movie (what she looked like at that time):



Many say CW is best, but I don't see it. Her nose is too dainty, and not upturned enough.

Eyes look surprised/startled on WS.

I still vote A1

AoU never gets voted on, but it holds it's own.

I loved her CW look

I've never seen any in person, accessories aside I actually like the IM2 look the best I think; I guess I'm crazy haha.

Craig Walker said:

HS side-by-side with movie (what she looked like at that time):

Many say CW is best, but I don't see it. Her nose is too dainty, and not upturned enough.

Eyes look surprised/startled on WS.

I still vote A1

AoU never gets voted on, but it holds it's own.

Click to expand...

Use the actual released figures not the protos. AoU and TWS really dont look like tbe protos, they have the dead stare and look like Natalie Portman more than Johansson.

Bjjer said:

Use the actual released figures not the protos. AoU and TWS really dont look like tbe protos, they have the dead stare and look like Natalie Portman more than Johansson.

Click to expand...

^ This. I've seen the A1 in hand & I had the WS. In hand, CW wins in likeness & has better life-like expression. The uniforms are all basically similar except AoU. The body on the AoU has got more curves.