I completely agree with everyone so far. It's certainly no better overall than KOTCS.
For one thing, it's far too self-referential. You've got characters spouting lines of dialogue from previous films (And even worse, from the previous posters! At one point, a character tells Indy that "back then, adventure had a name"! *cringe*), cameos from the Cross of Coronado
and the Fertility Idol (in a scene that actually recreates the pedestal switch from "Raiders", no less), it's all a bit much.
Marion
is written well, though; Darabont really seems to understand what she was all about. The "red scare" angle is played better here as well. It's also nice, I suppose, to see what Henry's role would have been (small, ultimately inconsequential and probably disappointing to the general moviegoer...like, "Wait, isn't he coming along this time? I liked him!"), and the inclusion of Sallah, even in
yet another cameo, will always be welcome in my book.
I don't know. There are moments that are, as Indy himself puts it, "swell", but as a whole, it's not nearly the work of genius a lot of fans seemed to think it'd be.
Besides, no Spalko. Boot hearts Spalko.