Gotta go with Dutch and Co. I got to see real marines at Basic, and saw that they were A) surprisingly like Hick's crew, and B) not terribly bright. Dutch's team seems more adaptable.
An amusing side story: I beat up my knee in Basic, and was placed on "Casual" status for the 8 weeks it took the Air Farce to process my paperwork. During this time, several of my fellow gimps and I went to see 'Aliens' at one of the Base theaters. Having had a less than pleasant time on base(anyone who tells you they had a good time in Basic is lying or completely insane) we were naturally rooting for the Aliens, much to the annoyance of the 5 guys in the back row. Turns out said 5 guys were Marines;my friends and I made sure to look VERY injured as we left...PS